The Gym Starter - Empowering Your Fitness Journey

View Original

How Do You Track Weight Loss With Progress Photos? And are Progress Photos useful to use?

The infamous “Progress” Picture. Some of this Article will sound damn obvious. Some of this article will shock you to your core.

But the overall aim of this Article is, like so much of my content, designed to change your perspective on two things:

  1. How you feel about your own “Progress” photos

  2. How you feel when you look at other people’s “Progress” photos.

One of my favorite progress photos is the following:

“I finally had the courage to upload my Progress Photo…it wasn’t easy but I managed it”

The reason I love this Meme so much is that it sums up the entire point of this Article.


Table of contents for: How Do You Track Weight Loss With Progress Photos? And are Progress Photos useful to use?

  1. What is a “Progress” photo?

  2. How should you view “Progress” photos?

  3. What are the Pros and Cons of “Progress” photos?

  4. How should you take a “Progress” photo?

  5. Conclusion


How Do You Track Weight Loss With Progress Photos? And are Progress Photos useful to use?

See this content in the original post

What is a “Progress” Photo?

I’m sure you have heard about them…or seen them. Even if you are ever so slightly interested in fitness or have ever logged into Facebook or Instagram I am almost certain you will have come across a Progress Photo.

A “Progress” Photo is a picture of someone on one day in time, typically when they started a new program placed right next to the same person a few months on when the program has finished.

And you are “expected” to see a difference between Photo A and Photo B.

They are also sometimes called “Before and After” photos.

I dislike this term more because it gives a finite beginning and end, which I don’t think is helpful for you.

Now it's great for the Personal Trainer that made you do it in your 12-week program and wants to exploit you and your pictures to try and get more clients…because as far as they are concerned it is Before and After.

Before you ever knew them.

After you are finished with them.

They now don’t give a fuck about you because they have their marketing photo. Its a classic, use, and abuse. In and Out. Kick to the curb.

And it disgusts me.

Disclaimer: I have been known to use my client's photos for marketing purposes. But none of them has ever done a 12-week shred with me. None of them have been with me as a client for less than a year. And they all understand that its a part of the sad world I exist in. I have also never edited a progress photo in order to create a better image of the result. But I am definitely in the minority.

I wish I could sell Personal Training without them. I really do. And I try to use them as little as possible. I very rarely use my own photos to sell how good I am as a Trainer because just because I can get a ripped body for myself doesn’t mean I know how to coach someone else to that end.

And that is a very important point. If you are choosing a Trainer based on how they look…then you are falling for a very easy trap. Anyone can follow a plan and get results themselves…the art of coaching is to be able to get someone else to do that, someone who isn’t you, who has a very different life and who needs very different guidance not just from who the trainer is, but also from all of their other clients too.

You are an individual.

And this is part of the problem. The market decides what sells…and you…yes…you…I know you have judged someone’s training experience based on a “Progress” photo you have seen of them. You have made a snap judgment on their trainer…and a snap judgment on the person based simply on a once in a moment photo.

And that is what sells.

I also think we all have a responsibility when posting them. Whether it is myself to try and garner business or yourself to demonstrate your hard work and to show how you have changed.

I always think…whenever I chose to use a “Progress” photo…I always think what effect will this have on someone somewhere?

Will one of my clients who is struggling right now see it and feel worthless?

Could someone see it at the wrong time of day and it means that they sink further into darkness?

Could it inspire someone to make a change?

I generally do not give a flying hoot about what I post and if someone is offended by what I say…I know they can move on, and I certainly can.

But a “Progress” photo has slightly different energy…and I have a responsibility to make sure that they are used in a more progressive way…and if you are reading this…I would like to think I have stopped and made you think about that too.

And this is based in reality. A trainer I used to work with created an online program that was based around a 6 Week Fat Loss shred. The image they used of their “client” (personally I had never seen them work with them and there was no Social proof for this either over the 5 years I had known said person) was of “this client” looking “large” and then “small”.

The tag line was “6 Week Transformation”

The advertising for this was huge. This woman was almost life-like in size on the website and the online ads and Social Media pictures were in your very in your face. But what really got to me about them was the following: It was all a lie.

  1. This “client” did not do this program.

  2. This “client” did not change her body that much in 6 weeks.

  3. The people who did do this program never got results like that in 6 weeks — so imagine how they must have felt when all was said and done?

Luckily, I never worked with the trainer personally…we were just both in the same industry in the same town. But this is what really hurt most about it.

I was in a session with a client. A client who has struggled with weight her entire life. The issues with her weight have permeated through into her Mental Health and for the first time in her life she felt like she was learning and beginning to get to where she wanted to get to.

She was targeted by this advert online and the posts…she sent them to me…feeling very lonely late one night and asked me:

“Is that true?”

I told her the truth that the whole thing is a lie and the transformation took a good four or five years, and her response was this:

“That makes me feel really sad. That makes me feel so small and so unworthy. I’m so glad it isn’t true, but that picture makes me feel so angry because for a while I thought it was true…and it made me feel horrible”

We have a responsibility. We need to do better. We need to stop putting finances above people’s mental health in an industry that is about Health. We must stop selling lies and impossible truths just because we have egos. It's not helping you, and it's not helping your clients.

The worst bit…the program did really well in terms of sales. The results? Well, I’ve never seen a “client” who actually went through the system on any campaign from this trainer since….nor have I seen any of their progress photos on social media.

This brings us quite nicely to…

How Do You Track Weight Loss With Progress Photos? And are Progress Photos useful to use?

See this content in the original post

How Should You View “Progress” Photos?

Let me be clear. As much as I think they can be bad for the majority of people to see…they do have a place and can be effective for you in tracking your goals. I think they are a terrible way to draw clients in due to how untrustworthy they really can be.

It's more like the “Progress” photo itself isn’t the problem…but like with all things it's the way we personally view them.

When I was at Drama School we would be constantly working on a play. And every so often different people would come into rehearsals and critique the play. Whether that was a Movement Director, a fellow student, a Fight Director, a Voice Coach, a Casting Director, a Producer, the productions Composer and the Lighting Designer. You also had the Set Designer, Costume Designer, Script Writer (if they were still alive…alas I never met Shakespeare). Oh, then there's the whole Stage Management Team as well.

All in all about 30 people.

That wasn’t involved in all of the rehearsals They just had to show up and go away again. But every time they would show up an interesting phrase kept creeping into the rehearsal room:

“It’s a work in progress”

I used to view this as an excuse in case the people watching thought it was totally rubbish…and we would have time to make it better.

Then I was in Twelfth Night…and our Director, James Kemp, spoke to us about how a play is never finished. How a Production is never finished. How every night you must keep digging and digging, you must keep finding new things to discover because that is how you keep a play alive.

And no one wants to sit through a very stagnant three hours of Shakespeare.

You see, this is what your “Progress” Photo is.

It's not a beginning and an end.

Your fitness, if you have taken it on, and want to improve it should never exist with the concept of a beginning and an end. You must always be searching, always be digging, always be developing and letting your experience reveal new truths to you as you go.

There is no end. Just exploration.

A “Progress” photo doesn’t do that. A “Before and After” photo doesn’t do that.

Therefore I think it is a lot more healthy for you to view these photos as

“Work In Process”

Not just your photos, but those of others you see on the internet as well. They are just Work In Process.

I take a photo of myself after every single training session.

And yes…I do have narcissistic tendencies, but that is not why.

Its a lot like my article on “Your Scale Strategy”

Read my article that has helped 100s of women improve their relationship with the scale right here: Your Scale Strategy

The more you expose yourself to a picture like this then the less pressure you will feel first when you see it of yourself, and secondly when you see others. Yes, you might not notice progress as much…but who cares? Like with everything in Fitness…there is no end game. There is no finite; just exploration.

All Work In Process photos must be taken with a huge pinch of salt because they are quite literally just an image of someone frozen in time.

The drawbacks of what you see in a Progress photo are huge.

How Do You Track Weight Loss With Progress Photos? And Are Progress Photos Useful To Use?

See this content in the original post

What are the Pros and Cons of “Progress” photos?

Well…as we are here…let's start with the Cons:

Some of the biggest cons are that you have no idea about these elements of the subject's health:

  • Their relationship with food

  • Their mental health

  • Their hydration levels

  • Their physical health

  • Their relationship with exercise

All of these things could be very much affected…and the more “drastic” a “progress” photo is…and the more professional the photos look the more extreme we can assume the pendulum swings.

I know of BodyBuilders that get to a point where they can only drink what they pass when getting ready for a photoshoot — they also can’t get health insurance…due to the state of their livers.

Yes…that is the extreme side of the equation. But it all counts. Because every time you flick through Instagram and see a very shredded person…it still makes you feel like crap. Even a little. It makes you say “I’d never be able to achieve that” and that isn’t good enough.

Some more cons:

  • It is well known that people have had their own “progress” photos stolen to sell products and programs they never participated in.

  • The use of lighting can affect a huge amount of the way you look when they are taken (there is actually a thing called “anabolic lighting”)

  • They can easily be edited to make the subject look a lot better than they are.

Here are two photos…one on the right I edited on my phone…and the other is the original.

Please excuse the towel…

See this content in the original post

You can see my Pecs look a lot bigger in the edited photo due to the enhanced shadow, and the coloring looks a little off…but you are comparing like for like. How many “Progress” photos do you see where the subject is comparing all things the same?

I used a specialist app to edit this photo and these are some of its features:

  • Reshape — including Detail and Bloat (this might sound defunct but it makes your muscles look so much bigger if used well)

  • Retouch — teeth whitening, smoothing.

  • Brighten / Darken (very useful for anabolic lighting)

  • Tall — yes, you can actually make yourself taller

But my favorite feature is the following:

  • Stickers — Male Ab Stickers, Male Chest Stickers, Female Ab Stickers, Collarbone Stickers, Cleavage Stickers (yes, you can actually put someone else's breasts on your photos — I use this feature personally a lot)

I was going to put a funny photo in here of myself with that feature…but some things just can't be unseen.

In the photo above, I have managed to increase my arm size, my pectoral size, and I was able to darken my Abs so they looked so much more defined, and so that I look a lot more muscly and ripped than I actually am.

It took 5 minutes. Maybe less.

And…this app…is totally free.

Other Cons?

  • They build pressure on you

  • They can de-motivate you when you don’t see any progress

  • They can feel like a much bigger deal than they actually are

  • They can be very exposing and scary if you have never done them before

  • If you don’t know how to look at them, and what to look for you may never see the progress in them. I have had a number of clients submit photos to me and despite huge differences, they just don’t see them. Being subjective towards them can be very diminishing. I’ve had full-blown discussions with clients to try and show them what I can see in a photo…they just never believe it.

And this is why I don’t think they are an effective way to draw clients into programs either…

Let’s say I took on 100 clients into a 12 week program and made them all eat 1000 calories or less each day. I would get some amazing before and after photos…trust me. Especially if I only took on clients who had a BMI of 25+ for this program.

Now only about 10% of that number would actually get to the end. I now have 10 clients.

Of these 10 clients, lets say…maybe 5 or 6 of them remembered to do their photos at the beginning, and maybe 2 or 3 remembered to do them at the end.

I had 100 clients. I now have 2 or 3 that I have amazing photos of…to then use to sell the advocacy of the program to you.

You are buying into a program that has revealed 3% of its truth.

If I gave you a 3% chance of success in any program would you want to spend £100s on that?

Hardly seems honest, does it?

97 people, who failed. 97 people who you have no idea about and 97 people who the trainer can’t even remember their names.

On the internet also…there are many accounts that produce these comparison photos…and I kid you not…they don’t even use the same person in both photos. This is no joke. I promise you.

When I saw this it got me thinking of a checklist you should probably ask yourself every time you see a “Before and After” photo. It's really important you protect yourself from stuff like this. So always use the following filter when you are looking at photos of this nature:

Are there any Pros?

Well, yes. There are.

Photos can be and should be used as another way to track your Work In Process. They can reveal a lot. They can reveal things that the scale might not reveal.

They can build huge confidence in people, as they can be challenging, and overcoming a challenge can move you into growth.

And when they reveal development…it is a great feeling.

It really is a nice feeling. But that is chased with trepidation because I’m sure in the past you haven’t seen progress from one photo to another…and it has stopped you in your tracks.

How Do You Track Weight Loss With Progress Photos? And Are Progress Photos Useful To Use?

See this content in the original post

How Should You Take A “Work In Process” Photo?

There are rules on how it should be done…and in all honesty mine are a terrible example for a number of reasons — which when I explain below you will understand more.

I would also like to take this moment to TELL YOU TO DO IT.

But only if you agree to the following:

1. Its a Work In Process photo and you remember that at all times — there is no end to the process.

2. You understand that its only one method of tracking your work in process — the scale, measurements, the way your clothes fit, and what other people say to you are all huge indicators of progress too.

3. You will only compare every two to three months (you can and should take them much more regularly so you get to practice and used to taking the photos)

4. You follow the best practice as laid out below…

If I had a dollar for every client that said to me…

“I wish I took photos at the beginning”

In fact just this week one of my clients in The Fitness Collective said just this. Word for word.

Get my enitre library of resources and learn how to Build Confidence, Burn Fat and Build Muscle by Joining the Fitness Collective right here: https://www.thegymstarter.com/the-fitness-collective-sign-up

And I understand why you don’t want to when you start.

You feel scared of failing, and you definitely don’t want a photo to remind you of another moment where you failed. Plus…you’re in this to lose weight…because deep down there are parts of your body you hate…and a “reveal all” photo to send to your trainer when you can’t even make love with the lights on just isn’t happening. Full Stop.

It is a challenge. And a photo isn’t mandatory. But if you have someone who believes in you, as much as I do. If you have someone who is your number one cheerleader then of course you aren’t going to fail and that photo could be something you are immensely proud of and giving yourself that opportunity could be life-changing.

So this is how you do it:

1. Always take your progress photos at the same time of day. Mornings are preferred…as much fewer variables are in play ie: how much food you have eaten that day and therefore how bloated you are.

2. Try and use natural lighting as much as possible. Go outside and get the photo as it is going to be a much truer reflection.

3. Use the same clothing — never change your clothing. It's ok to have a progress photo in a T-shirt, but remember that won’t tell you the whole story…but if you need that comfort that’s ok. But always where the same one!

4. Use the same phone, and put it in the same position! Do not change lenses, do not change angles and do not do it like a selfie. In fact the phone should always be lower than you think. Usually, the best position for the phone in relation to you is about in line with your belt buckle.

5. Put the phone about 6 feet away from you so you can capture your whole body from toe to head on the screen.

6. Keep the phone completely parallel to your body. Do not angle it upwards or downward as it is a variable you will not be able to repeat.

6. Stand naturally…no flexing, no tensing, and no worry. Just be you. Because you are all that matters.

7. Try to put the gridlines evenly across your body, and make sure you stand in the center three boxes. Like this:

And that’s it.

Nearly.

Now the photo is taken…

You then have to wait a minimum of 8 weeks and then repeat the process.

Then…and this is probably the most important part of Work In Process photo.

Send the photos to a professional who can look at them objectively.

I promise you…you won’t see what they see…and what they see is what is really going on. You will be hell-bent on seeing a reduction in your belly, but you will ignore all the differences in your posture, your muscular development, the difference in confidence and so much more.

It takes practice and work to really see what is going on in photos…and that is something you do not have experience in.

I tell you what…if you got this far in this article…email me and I will look at them myself for you…to help you…just email me on adam@thegymstarter.com

How Do You Track Weight Loss With Progress Photos? And Are Progress Photos Useful To Use?

See this content in the original post

Conclusion

I really hope your biggest take away from this article is the following:

Stop viewing these photos as “Progress” photos or “Before and After” photos. Looking at them in that mindset is helping people manipulate you into buying into very large untruths about their work and the effectiveness of losing weight.

I want you to start realizing they are a “Work In Process” photo.

There is no end. It's just where you are at over this last two to three month period.

A Work In Process photo is useful, but it only reveals one very small and slim side of someone's story. It doesn’t tell you their relationship with food, what drastic measures they have had to go through to get the photo in the first place.

Its just two photos…two or three months apart. You have no idea how happy that person is…and I bet even though they lost some weight…they still aren’t happy.

Because this is the kicker: Losing Weight doesn’t make you happy.

The work and focus on the process of looking after yourself might. But reducing the size of your body will not make you happy…so stop thinking that it will…and above all stop thinking that the people you see in these photos are happy.

If they look happier on one photo compared to another its because they have manipulated it that way…they have slouched and sunken in the first one and stood up straight in the second one.

There’s more to this than you think.

So let's get you focussed on the Process. On the work. On the toil.

And let's get you viewing these photos with a more critical eye when you see them….

And let's get you viewing your own ones as quite simply…

A Work In Process.

Because that is beautiful. Just like you.

Did you find this useful?

You can Join The Fitness Collective which is my Membership Group. In there I give Monthly Updates, Live Q and A’s, I provide you with new workouts each and every month, and write guidance on your fitness journey.

To find out more about The Fitness Collective you can click here: The Fitness Collective

Please share this with your friends and anyone else you may know who is worried about training in a gym, and feel free to follow me using the links below…

And if you want to get updates on when I publish new articles, publish new podcasts or anything else then please remember to sign up below

And above all remember this…for as long as you are trying your best no one can ask for more from you.

Coach Adam

See this content in the original post